| 03-13-2003 | Police report | Report of police officers called to the scene of the murder. |
| Police interview notes | Notes from an 11:55 am police interview of Jeremy at the scene. "I did her in." Got knife from kitchen. Flushed vitamins. I hid in bedroom because she would know I had something to do with this. | |
| CPL 710.30 Attachment | Summary of verbal statements Jeremy made to the police at his home and in a patrol car. | |
| Miranda waiver Seach and seizure waivers (3 pages) | Jeremy signed a Miranda waiver agreeing to speak with the Amherst police, and search waiver forms allowing the police to search his body, his clothing, and his bedroom, a few hours after Elli's death. | |
| Jeremy's statement to police | A written statement Jeremy gave to the police at 1:30 pm, a few hours after the murder. She was screaming no, don't, Jeremy no don't. I stabbed her about 4-5 times before she fell down... | |
| Monthly psych consults (4 pages) | Brief updates on patient status and medication; March through July, 2003. | |
| 04-07-2003 | Psych evaluations (3 pages) | Mental status evaluation by Joseph W. Liebergall, Ph.D., and psychiatric assessment by Brian S. Joseph, M.D., indicating chronic paranoid schizophrenia. |
| 06-03-2003 |
Indictment (2 pages) Prosecutor's letter Alibi demand Prosecutor's notice of intention to offer evidence at trial |
Indictment number 00586-2003, for murder in the second degree. Erie County Court, State of New York. And an alibi demand and notice of intention to offer evidence (standard paperwork accompanying an indictment.) |
| 06-04-2003 |
Defense notice of intention to
present psychiatric evidence Demand for Discovery (6 pages) |
Jeremy's defense attorney, John R. Nuchereno, asks district attorney Frank J. Clark, III to disclose the evidence against his client. This is standard procedure. |
| 06-06-2003 | Notice of pretrial conference | Letter from Judge Shirley Troutman to John Nuchereno setting a pretrial conference for June 19, 2003. |
| 06-19-2003 | Defense notice of motion (2 pages) Motion schedules (34 pages) Affirmation |
A set of standard defense motions for discovery, disclosure, suppression of evidence, etc. Submitted to Judge Shirley Troutman. |
| 07-29-2003 | Investigation memorandum | Erie County Probation Department memorandum indicating that Jeremy was convicted on July 29, 2003. "Not responsible by reason of mental disease or defect." |
| 09-29-2003 | Psychiatric examination: Dr. Yerneni (15 pages; text version) | Mental status examination by Dr. Srinivas Yemeni, indicating schizophrenia, paranoid type, drug and alcohol abuse, and poor social support. |
| 12-26-2003 | Psychiatric examination order (4 pages) | After finding Jeremy not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, Judge Troutman orders another psychiatric examination to determine whether he remains mentally ill and potentially dangerous. |
| 01-09-2004 | Psychiatric examination: Dr. Rosenberg (9 pages; text version) | Schizophrenic and acutely psychotic. |
| 01-13-2004 | Psychiatric examination: Dr. Singh (9 pages; text version) | Mental status examination by Dr. R. P. Singh, indicating chronic paranoid schizophrenia, and alcohol and cannabis abuse. Note: MICA stands for "Mentally Ill / Chemically Addicted". |
| 01-27-2004 | Commitment order (3 pages) and Transmittal letter |
Order finding Jeremy to be suffering from a dangerous mental disorder and committing him to a state hospital for six months, and a letter transmitting this order to the Commisioner of the State Office of Mental Health. |
